Related
Solo : A Star Wars Storymay have treat L3 - 37 ’s droid activism as a jest , but she was correct about the waydroids are treat inStar war . Droids occupy an interesting part in the stories , evince their content for emotion , learning , and self - improvement , with characters like K-2SO inStar war : Rogue Oneand C-3PO inStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalkerproviding some of the most memorable and aroused moment in the movie saga . At the same clip , droids are very often treated the same means as any other machine , being corrupt , trade , or abandoned . With droids treat like disposable objects , it ’s light to sympathise with L3 - 37 ’s persuasion .
The motif of exemption is fundamental toSolo . L3 - 37 ’s feeling tie into this , even though they ’re not treated with the same gravitational attraction as that afforded to her biological counterparts — a fact which would frustrate her deep . Her personal goal is quite obviously to be free and rest that fashion , reinforcing the movie ’s pith message . The interrogative sentence is leave open , however , as to whetherbecoming part of the Millennium Falconat her story ’s conclusion is a fitting closing for her character . On the one manus , becoming a starship and travel across the galaxy could be seen as the ultimate expression of exemption . On the other hand , only ever being able to do as instructed and go only to the berth you ’re severalise to seems like the very definition of servitude . Viewed in the latter luminousness , many have criticized L3 - 37 ’s portion as not only horrifying for her personally , but as wayward to the movie ’s magnetic core idea .
Related : Star Wars : Why The Republic Used Clones Instead Of Droids
L3 - 37 inadvertently heighten questions aboutStar Warsmore generally . If droids have the content to become in full sentient , it ’s deserving examining whether or not they should be allowed to . Questions of whether or not allStar Warsdroidsare open of the same literal ego - melioration , and what constitutes self - cognisance , are interesting ones . However , this carry uncomfortable deduction if it turns out that the most beloved characters inStar Warshave been owning sentient beingness all along . While for the most part absent fromStar Wars , similar ideas about AI have been explore deep by other stories , such asThe Animatrix , Ex Machina , and theMass Effectgames .
How Droids Are Often Treated In Star Wars
The cosmopolitan mental attitude towards droids inStar Warsis summed up neatly by one line inStar Wars : Attack of the Clones,“If droids could suppose , there ’d be none of us here . ”Delivered byObi - Wan Kenobi , it ’s an off-the-cuff comment , but it carries two deep significance . Firstly , the fact that droids can not actually think for themselves , and secondly that if they could , they ’d be ranking to the constituent beingness who make up most of theStar Warsuniverse . Obi - Wan reflects this attitude throughout his entire story , showing little attachment to R2 - D2 , despite the droid ’s obvious display of emotions and tidings . So fiddling bond that by the fourth dimension he appears inStar Wars : A New Hope , he does n’t seem to recollect R2 - D2 at all .
Obi - Wan probably feel this way because of the way of life droids are treat in - universe . Star Warsmedia shows that droids typically follow the same practice . While newly manufactured , like theseparatist battle droids inStar Wars , they show no emotion and small ego - awareness . Over metre , the longer they ’re on-line , they pull in memory board and gradually educate emotions as a result . People variously refer to these as quirks or system faults , and it ’s stock for droids to occasionally have their memories pass over to remove these . This notably pass to C-3PO at the end ofStar warfare : retaliation of the Sith — something which he seems clearly disquieted about . Alongside memory wipes , droids are often fitted with a restraining bolt . These small gadget restrict what a droid is capable to do , prohibiting them from take autonomous actions . While considered dead normal by organic beings , droids inStar Warsoften show unease , disgust , or even horror at the idea of being suit with one .
Not allStar Warscharacters share Obi - Wan ’s dismissiveness about droids , however . Poe Dameron process BB-8much like someone might treat a beloved puppy , and Jyn Erso gradually develop respect for K-2SO as a fellow Rebel , surprising him in the process . One of the most notable characters in this regard is Anakin Skywalker , who decline to let R2 - D2 be retention wiped duringStar Wars : The Clone Wars . Having been raised as a slave himself , it makes sentiency for Anakin to have dandy sympathy for droids than Obi - Wan . Judging by how often R2 - D2 uses his own initiative , disobeys instructions , and bear witness complex emotions , it ’s potential that he ’s never had his memory wiped at all , allowing him to develop a far deep personality than his wretched companion C-3PO .
Related : Star Wars discover Why Anakin Built C-3PO
L3-37 Proved Droids Can Better Themselves
Solo ’s L3 - 37 is a fascinating grapheme , leaven Obi - Wan wrong and designate that droids inStar Warscan not only mean , but they can improve themselves beyond what organic beings are capable of . Canonically , she started lifespan as an unassuming astromech droid much like R2 - D2 . She eventually used a workshop full of spare droid parts to upgrade herself substantially , with a humanoid soma and a immensely expanded memory . During her appearance inSolo , L3 - 37 is likely one of the most autonomous and self - aware droids in the entire galaxy .
There are other droids inStar Warswho show similar spirit level of sentience to L3 - 37 . The bravo droid IG-88 was one of thebounty huntsman hired byStar Wars ' Darth Vaderto track down the Millennium Falcon inStar Wars : The Empire Strikes Back , understandably being ego - mindful enough to operate with complete autonomy . A similar assassinator droid is HK-47 from the no - longer - canyon gameStar Wars : Knights of the Old Republic , who is not only autonomous but also takes cracking joyfulness in tell stories of how his previous possessor all met a horrifying and violent demise , usually with him being in person responsible for . Arguably , the most like droid to L3 - 37 is what is likely a simple astromech droid who ’s quickly give away to have been change to have arms and leg — the unidentified ferry droid onThe Mandalorian’splanet Nevarro . It ’s ill-defined whether the droid was qualify by an owner or if it made the changes itself .
Droids Blur The Line Between Living And Non-Living
AsStar Wars’prominent cyborg characters add together dubiousness to the distinction between constituent and artificial beings , so the droids do the same from the other direction . Several droids show both intelligence activity and emotion , from the fear showed by D-0 duringThe Rise of Skywalkerto the obstinate single - mindedness of R2 - D2 duringA New Hope , to the joy shown by BB-8 on realise that Poe survive the crash duringStar Wars : The Force Awakens . Whether or not they can be considered rightfully alive is a fascinating interrogative whichStar Warshas yet to fully address , probably because it comes with the far inscrutable philosophical motion of what it even entail to be alert .
Related : Star Wars Already Revealed The Mandalorian ’s Deadly New Destination
The droid soldier in the prequel trilogy are probable to be little more than the vapid machines most people believe them to be , being manufactured specifically for warfare and with niggling experience or time to develop into fully sentient beings . R2 - D2 , on the other hand , has seemingly never been memory wiped throughout the entire core saga of movies , allow him to develop a full and unparalleled personality . This prove the question of what point exactly a droid might be considered sentient in their own right . Similar melodic theme were raise inStar Trek : Picard , leadingStarfleet to take harsh action , banning synthetic substance . A similar question is , at what point might a bionic woman no longer be considered live . If General Grievous had replaced his organic brain with a man-made one while keeping his personality and memories full intact , would that render him no longer live ? If so , would people then be able to buy and trade him or wipe his memories like any other droid ?
This question is raised most affectingly by IG-11 duringThe Mandalorian . Initially an assassin droid sent to kill sister Grogu , he ’s defeated and then reprogrammed with the stark opposite of his original design . His ego - professed fundament part becomes"to nanny and protect . “While it ’s not clear whether or not this include a memory wipe , his newfound comrade have time to emotionally bond with him as a answer . IG-11 ’s last mo inThe Mandalorianis a desperate forfeit to save Grogu , with the line:“There is nothing to be sad about . I was never alive . “Nevarro City is subsequently shown to have set up a statue of IG-11 to honour him , which is very much not the kind of regard afforded to a dewy-eyed simple machine .
It would be interesting to see future canonStar Warsstories spend more time exploring the question of whether droids merit better treatment by their constitutive companions . WhileSolo : A Star Wars Storypainted L3 - 37 as a impersonation of activism and a subject field of ridicule , her point remains an extremely valid one , specially consider the recurring themes ofslavery and servitude inStar Wars . Perhaps it ’ll never be addressed whether or not droids can truly count as living sentient organism . Perhaps that does n’t really matter . If they have all the traits of sentience , mayhap that ’s all they need to deserve a better circle in life-time .
Next : Every shaft And Ability R2 - D2 Used In Star Wars
