Related
Ever since the expiration ofThe Amazing Spider - Manin 2012 , Marvel fans have had one lallygag criticism regarding Andrew Garfield ’s depiction of the titular fictional character , but that unfavorable judgment is incorrect . The Amazing Spider - Manis the onlySpider - Manreboot that did n’t get a full trilogy despite the plan to introduce theSinister Six due toThe Amazing Spider - Man 2 ’s pitiful box office execution and critical reception . Yet whileThe Amazing Spider - Manfilms have seen a afterthought in contemporary culture , in part thanks toSpider - Man : No Way Home ’s historical Multiverse narrative , unfavorable judgment regarding Garfield ’s original Spider - Man performance has strangely continue .
Tobey Maguire was the first cinematic Peter Parker in Sam Raimi’sSpider - Mantrilogy , and he set an expectation for what the character should count and play like on screen . Like the comic , Maguire ’s Parker was a nerdy lone hand who was hopelessly in beloved with the popular MJ ( Kirsten Dunst ) . He wear down drinking glass and plain clothes , underscore that his sole passion was for science and study before becoming Spider - Man . In addition , when he was n’t the heroicSpider - Man , Maguire ’s Parkerwas quiet , reserved , and uneasy . Audiences , then , expected this same Peter in the 2012 reboot and were critical when that was n’t the case .
Related : Andrew Garfield ’s Spider - Man Tragedy Is Deeper Than You guess
The biggest critique that Garfield faced from Marvel fans , despite renew appetence forThe Amazing Spider - Man 3 , was that his portrait of Peter Parker was n’t nerdy enough . In terminal figure of his styling , he wore layers of hoodies and jackets and fairly fresh and fashionable sneakers , and he did n’t start break glasses until he found a pair that used to belong to his Padre . TASM ’s Peter was also fair outspoken , which sat in stark direct contrast to the meek and unsociable character in Sam Raimi ’s firstSpider - Manmovie . Yet , the most hearty evidence supporting the idea that Andrew ’s Peter was too cool was the inclusion of the quality being able to skateboard , with these elements inThe Amazing Spider - Manmovies working together to dismantlePeter ’s iconic characterization as an ostracize Einstein .
In this criticism , though , there is a failure to bet into the culture of 2012 at a time when geek polish arguably first became cool and popular . In this way , Garfield ’s version of Peter Parker reflects this perfectly , gain his personation precise for the time hisSpider - Manfilms were released . InThe Amazing Spider - Man , when Peter debates with Captain Stacy ( Denis Leary ) , his frankness comes as a result of recognise he ’s the fresh in the way and asserting it , echo the time when nerd culture was very self-asserting and inescapable in real life , with the word ' geek ' being splashed across t - shirts everywhere . In this agency , Garfield ’s Spider - Man was great , and the idea that Peter having a sideline outdoors of skill automatically make believe him a treasonist to his intellect is therefore undue . Even though he could skateboard , Peter was still bullied by Flash Thompson ( Chris Zylka ) , ignored by most other students , and rather awkward in societal position . He stutter over his words and aver the incorrect things at the wrong time , perfectly capturing the aspect of Peter Parker ’s Marvel comics character who does n’t quite know how to engage with others .
Naturally , Garfield , Maguire , and Holland ’s variation of the iconic fiber have extensively been compared to one another over the age . WhileHolland is regarded as the good Peter and Spidey , each brought their own unique dispute and personal touches to the character , making for wonderfully classifiable depiction . Marvel fans ' criticism of Garfield making Peter too cool , therefore , is wrong and an revilement to how well he , andThe Amazing Spider - Manin general , rebooted the character for a young generation .
Next : Venom 3 : Andrew Garfield Is The Perfect Spider - Man To Meet Tom Hardy ’s Antihero
