The Rise of Skywalker Made Snoke's Last Jedi Death Worse

Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi

The death of Supreme Leader Snoke inStar warfare : The Last Jediwas already controversial , but the reveal of Snoke ’s origins inStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalkeronly made it worse . Instead of being a formidable character in his own right , Snoke sprain out to be nothing more than a clone who was being puppeteered by Emperor Palpatine .

Star Wars : The Last Jediwas the most divisive motion picture in the franchise yet , with some lover declare it to be their Modern dearie and others arguing that it ruined Disney ’s sequel trilogy . Director Rian Johnson ’s cinema counteract much of whatStar Warshad brought people to have a bun in the oven , literallyburning down part of Jedi historyand revealing that Rey did n’t have any heroic patrimony or pedigree , but was the daughter of junk monger who had sold her for drinking money .

concern : The Last Jedi ’s Snoke Reveal Is The Best Movie Twist In yr

After the explosive answer toThe Last Jedi , Star war : The ascension of Skywalkerscrambled to contribute the dealership back to a safer place . Palpatine was brought back from the deadto give rooter a intimate villain , and Rey was break to be Palpatine ’s granddaughter in a clumsy retcon ofThe Last Jedi ’s twist . However , alternatively of the clone reveal fixing Snoke ’s sudden end inThe Last Jedi , it really retroactively made it worse .

Snoke’s Last Jedi Death Was Controversial - But Great

Supreme Leader Snoke was ab initio built up as the big badness of Disney’sStar Warssequel trilogy , and in typical J.J. Abrams way the character ’s identicalness was a enigma box , with nothing hump about his origins . But instead of answering big interrogative sentence about Snoke or having a gilded revelation ( like Luke discovering Darth Vader is his Padre inThe Empire Strikes Back ) , the twist ofStar Wars : The Last Jediis Kylo Ren turn on his master and cutting him in half before teaming up with Rey to take on the Praetorian guards . The two character were only on the same side briefly , until Rey rejected Kylo Ren ’s offering to prevail the galaxy with him . Kylo Ren was then elevated to the view of the main scoundrel of the net movie in the trilogy , which could have pore whole on the tortured enmity between him and Rey .

Snoke ’s death threw the enfranchisement off the path of have Snoke as just another Palpatine - a wizened , dark Force user controlling a younger adherent - and in doing so avert the risk of the subsequence trilogy being just aretread of the original trilogy ’s plot line . Or at least it would have , ifStar war : The boost of Skywalkerhadn’t forcibly shoved the franchise right back onto that track by bringing back Palpatine himself .

Rise of Skywalker Gave Snoke An Unnecessary Origin

Just asStar Wars : The Last Jedigave a blunt answer to themystery of Rey ’s parentsby revealing that they were nobodies , so too did it cut short the whodunit of Snoke ’s origins , since they do n’t on the dot count much after he was cut in one-half . But afterThe Last Jedidid away with Snoke , Star Wars : The Rise of Skywalkerinsisted on replacing him with another malefic overlord who was controlling the First Order , and descend up with an account for how Snoke could have effectively just been Palpatine in another form all along . As Kylo Ren record Palpatine ’s lairon Exegol , he fade by tanks full of go wrong Snoke ringer , divulge that the so - called Supreme Leader was just one of Palpatine ’s creations .

touch : Palpatine Was Originally Hiding On Coruscant In Rise of Skywalker

This origin story was wholly unnecessary . Snoke could just have easy been a powerful Force drug user who had risen up through the ranks of the First Order in his own right . The clone unwrap instead more or less entirely write him off as the character , twist him into just a mask that Palpatine was using . This is actually worse than Snoke being a recap of Emperor Palpatine , as he was inStar Wars : The Force Awakens- not least because it undermines one of Kylo Ren ’s good character moment .

Rise of Skywalker’s Snoke Reveal Makes His Last Jedi Death Worse

Like many elements ofStar Wars : The ascent of Skywalker , the Snoke reveal appeared contrive to gruntle complaint aboutThe Last Jedi , but instead only served to undermine the midway moving-picture show of the trilogy . In Snoke ’s case , it seems that Rise of Skywalker was attempting to lenify fans who were upset that the mystery ofSnoke ’s originwas never reveal . But respond that question by showing that Snoke was just a knockoff being controlled by Palpatine is both a unsatisfying conclusion to that finicky mystery for those dysphoric with how Snoke died , and makes his death worse for those who liked that second inThe Last Jedi .

For Kylo Ren , call on on his overlord was a immense eccentric here and now . As hardening - up for the third movie in the trilogy , it could have either lead to a story where he embraces his role as drawing card ofthe First Orderand becomes a character equal to Palpatine in metier and villainy , or to a redemption electric discharge where killing Snoke mark his first step back towards the light side of the Force . Revealing that Snoke was just a ringer , and one of many , weakens that minute for Kylo Ren . It would be like ifReturn of the Jediwas abide by by an epilog explaining that Darth Vader did n’t in reality throw Palpatine into the Death Star nuclear reactor ; it was just a mannequin that look like Palpatine . ( In fact , The wage increase of Skywalkerdoes come close to that by revealing that Darth Vader did n’t successfully shell Palpatine after all ) .

Ultimately , Snoke ’s journeying from beingset up as Palpatine 2.0 , to being reduce down by his own disciple , and lastly becoming a puppet of Emperor Palpatine is yet another unfortunate upshot of misfortunate planning for theStar Warssequel trilogy . It ’s open that the rendering of Snoke who was introduced inStar war : The Force Awakenswasn’t supposed to be a clone made by Emperor Palpatine , and so as a character he is built up only to peter out out . His death inStar state of war : The Last Jediwas one of the best moment of the motion picture , and it should have been the last we find out of him .