Since Sam Raimi revolutionized superhero celluloid with 2002’sSpider - Man , three actors have played Peter Parker in major blockbuster franchises . Tobey Maguire play the web - slinger in Raimi ’s trilogy , then Andrew Garfield took on the part in the badly - fatedAmazing Spider - Manreboot series , and the role is currently filled by Tom Holland in the sprawling Marvel Cinematic Universe .

Each of these doer has their own individual merit , and a great deal of critics have adjudge Holland to be the best Spidey yet , but it ’s arguably Maguire who did the finest line of work of play this character . So , here are 10 cause why Tobey Maguire is still the good Peter Parker .

His Double Life Is Palpably Hectic

Being Spider - Man is n’t easy . Whereas Tony Stark can excuse himself from a cocktail political party , summon hisIron Manarmor , and disappear to go and fight some terrorists whenever he wants , Peter Parker has to jump through all kinds of hoops to keep his identity operator a unavowed and live on a twofold living as a superhero .

Maguire ’s Peter embodied this perfectly . He struggled to keep up with his commitment to high shoal and later college , as well as holding down two jobs ( freelance photographer and pizza pie pitch guy ) to pay the rent for his crummy flat .

He Came Off As Genuinely Dorky

Peter Parker is a dork , but hunky actor like Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland have n’t been able to convincingly pull off that aspect of the character reference . Garfield ’s Peter was an all - out stud poker and Holland ’s Peter is undeniably awkward , butstill overwhelmingly charming .

Tobey Maguire is the only histrion who has played Peter as a full - blown dweeb . When he ’s taking pictures for the school paper , he ’s genuinely nerdy . Holland ’s Peter constantly dump school to fight crime , but Maguire ’s Peter makes a conjunctive effort to do well in his studies .

His Villain Dynamics Were Deeply Personal

Spidey has always had personal relationships with his villain , but Tobey Maguire ’s Peter Parker had cryptical , intimate dynamic with his enemies . Peter idolized Otto Octavius . Eddie Brock envy Peter . Flint Marko off Uncle Ben . Harry Osborn was his practiced protagonist , consumed by green-eyed monster and mislaid hate .   Most of all , Norman Osborn saw Peter as the son he never had , disappointed with Harry ’s lack of academic prowess .

These connections between the alter egos of the movies ’ hero and their baddie total layers of emotional rapport . The Amazing Spider - Manmovies tried to force these connections , but they never mat up real , andthe MCU has come close(but at last ties them more to Iron Man than Peter Parker ) , but not as well as Raimi ’s trilogy .

He Confronted His Mistakes

Andrew Garfield ’s Peter Parker never got a chance to present the fact that he let Gwen Stacy conk and did n’t bring through her in clock time , becausehis enfranchisement was scratch , but we did see him mourn silently through several season .

Tom Holland ’s Peter has only ever confronted one mistake : not being Tony Stark , which is n’t really his fault . But Tobey Maguire ’s Peter faced his mistakes . Hecame clean to Aunt Mayabout let Uncle Ben ’s murderer get to him .

He Always Struggled With His Powers

For Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland ’s Spider - Men , the powers of web - slinging and wallcrawling were gifts that kept on giving . But for Tobey Maguire ’s Spidey , those superpowers were both a gift and a condemnation , add up perfectly by Uncle Ben : “ With capital power comes great province . ”

InSpider - Man 2 , he began to lose his tycoon , which gave him the freedom to return to his even life as Peter Parker . But he ultimately had to figure out that being Spider - Man was about more than just power that he acquire by chance .

His Voiceover Narration Is The Best Cinematic Portrayal Of The Comics’ Thought Bubbles

One of the define characteristics of Spidey in the comics is his thought bubble . When he ’s dangle through New York or staking out a villain , we can read everything that ’s going through his caput . This is a lot easy to take out off in amusing book form than in movie form .

In the MCU’sSpider - Manmovies , this is achieved through Peter ’s conversations with the A.I. in his suit , but that ’s not the same affair . Tobey Maguire ’s voiceover narration in Raimi’sSpider - Manmovies is the closest the motion picture have come to translating those cerebrate bubbles to the screen .

He Was An Outsider

Tobey Maguire has said that what ab initio trace him to Peter Parker was identifying with him as an outsider . Even in his relationship with his closest friends , Maguire ’s Peter seems to be at arm ’s distance , struggling to meet in .

Andrew Garfield ’s Peter became cocky and arrogant and begin bully his rowdy as before long as he get his powers , whileTom Holland ’s Peterdoesn’t have a problem make ally or getting invited to party .

He Faced Consequences For His Actions

Starting with rent the mugger escape cock , guide to Uncle Ben ’s death , Tobey Maguire ’s Peter Parker always faced horrific consequences for his actions . If he did something tough , then something bad occur to him , forcing him to check and acquire .

His forked life as Spider - Man drive off his love sake and his best booster . Maguire ’s Peter was completely on his own . Tom Holland ’s Spideycan always rely on Tony Stark ’s resources to get him out of a jam , even after Stark ’s expiry .

He Had The Closest Relationship With Uncle Ben

As the confining affair that Peter Parker had to a father , Uncle Ben is incredibly significant to Spider - Man ’s character development . Tobey Maguire ’s Peter has the closest relationship with Uncle Ben out of all the big - CRT screen Spider - Men .

Andrew Garfield ’s Peter was n’t especially unaired with Martin Sheen ’s Uncle Ben , andTom Holland ’s Peter has n’t even observe that he ever had an Uncle Ben , although it ’s been inculpate a couple of time . Maguire ’s Peter prepare a genuine don - Word bond with Cliff Robertson ’s Ben Parker .

The Subway Scene In Spider-Man 2 Captures The Character Perfectly

No conniption in anySpider - Manmovie has captured the characterbetter than the subway system sequenceinSpider - Man 2 . Spidey ’s battle with Doc Ock takes him onto a bucket along train and the nefarious tentacled villain busts up the controls so that it set out careening toward an incomplete surgical incision of a bridge circuit .

Webhead springs into action , doing everything in his top executive to bestow the train to a halt , before being carried into the gear , unconscious , by concerned New Yorkers . With his masque run , they can see thatthe hero celebrate across the metropolis is just a kid .

NEXT : Batman : 10 reasonableness Why Michael Keaton Is Still The good Bruce Wayne

Spider-Man Noir

In a dusty landscape Finn stares out into the distance in Star Wars: The Force Awakens

A collage image of Luke Skywalker in A New Hope

Tobey Maguire as Spider-Man

Peter Parker holding a large tower of pizzas in Spider-Man 2.

Tobey Maguire as Peter Parker and Kirsten Dunst as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 2002

Octavius and his wife sitting at a table in Spider-Man 2

Peter Parker and Aunt May in Spider-Man 2

An unmasked Spider-Man attempts to shoot a web in Spider-Man.

Entry 2 Toby Maguire Spider-man Cropped

Spider-Man with his mask off looking into the distance in Spider-Man

James Franco as Harry Osborn in Spider-Man 3

Cliff Robertson Uncle Ben

Spider-Man fighting Doc Ock on a train in Spider-Man 2

Movies