Related
Why did n’t Viggo Mortensen make up one’s mind to return as Aragorn inThe Hobbit ? Peter Jackson made cinematic chronicle with his groundbreakingTheLord of the Ringstrilogy and despite manyTolkienpurists admit exception to some of the alteration made in interlingual rendition , the motion picture are mostly faithful to the beginning material , certainly in comparability to Jackson ’s more late adaptation ofThe Hobbit . descend from only a unmarried , modest volume , Jackson spreadThe Hobbitover an intact trilogy and incorporate ideas from elsewhere in Tolkien ’s canyon that build towards major effect inThe Lord of the Rings , such as the Necromancer .
As part ofThe Hobbit ’s Jacksonification , several familiar face fromThe Lord of the Ringswere blueprint in to further bind the two trilogies together . Aside from Gandalf , Elrond and Gollum , who all look in the original novel anyway , theHobbittrilogyalso let in Cate Blanchett ’s Galadriel and Christopher Lee ’s Saruman as phallus of the White Council . By far the most jarring film - only addition toThe Hobbit , however , is Orlando Bloom ’s Legolas . Legolas ' bearing inThe Hobbitarguably makes logical sense since he ’s the boy of Thranduil and dwells in Mirkwood , but others might evoke the front of a majorLord of the Ringscharacter made for an unnecessary improver and a transparent marketing ploy .
Related : Lord of the Rings : Why Smeagol Is call Gollum
InThe Battle of Five Armies , Thranduil necessitate his son to research for a Texas Ranger by the name of Strider , cite Viggo Mortensen ’s character from theLord of the Ringstrilogy , but programme were ab initio afoot to physically includeAragornin theHobbitmovies . According to Mortensen himself , an unnamedHobbitproducer approached the thespian in 2008 to go out a likely return for Aragorn . Mortensen pass up by simply saying , " you do roll in the hay , do n’t you ? Aragorn is n’t in The Hobbit . "
Since this exchange occurred in 2008 , the idea to bring back Aragorn ca n’t needs be attributed to Peter Jackson . Although Jackson was involved at this early microscope stage , Guillermo Del Toro was still in the director ’s president and conduce to the hand . With that said , the fact that Mortensen was n’t approach by Del Toro in person might suggest the Aragorn architectural plan was n’t his doing either . A more likely explanation is that producers were exploring ways to ride on the coattail ofLord of the Rings ' winner and casually sound out actors potentially willing to retrovert . Orlando Bloom ’s mien in theHobbittrilogy leaven the whimsey was never dropped .
Even though many viewers were critical of Legolas ' inclusion inThe Hobbit , the pixie is well-fixed to desegregate into the narrative than Aragorn due to the Mirkwood connection . If Mortensen had fit in to come back , his visual aspect would ’ve in all likelihood bring forth even more controversy than Bloom ’s . In theory , Jackson could have interpolate the appointment Aragorn metGandalfand delved into that duo ’s other dealings in addition to the Necromancer material , but this would ’ve spawned a completely disjoined narration , whereas at least Legolas could be work into the central journeying of Bilbo and the Dwarves .
Mortensen ’s respect for Tolkien ’s books and desire to be authentic to the source fabric would no doubt have earned him the admiration of many midway - earth fans , but also foreground the immensely differing attitudes amongLord of the Ringscast member . While some were happy to expand and adapt their characters in way original to the big CRT screen , others were sticklers for fidelity . For instance , Christopher Leewas an zealous Tolkien fan and became famous for carrying copies of the books on - set for reference . Although he no doubt would ’ve received a bumper payday , Mortensen might ’ve make out that his role ’s tax return inThe Hobbitwould not be well received and take a chance sully Aragorn ’s cinematic bequest .
More : Lord of the Rings : How Old Each Fellowship Member Really Is
