Related
Here ’s howFullmetal AlchemistandFullmetal Alchemist : Brotherhooddiffer from each other . Created by Hiromu Arakawa , Fullmetal Alchemistis one of the most democratic and successful manga serial of all time and has been developed into life , moving-picture show andlive - action . While it ’s commonplace for a hit manga to be given the anime adaptation treatment , it’snotstandard drill for there to be two disjoined serial free-base on precisely the same material . This is the situation fan find themselves in withFullmetal Alchemist .
The originalFullmetal Alchemistanime start air within a year of the manga ’s publication debut . make to different docket , Arakawa encourage the anime to deviate from her own fib and come up with something original . unluckily , anime master often run to be divisive , and so it proved withFullmetal Alchemist , leading to the production ofFullmetal Alchemist : Brotherhoodin 2009 which was more authentic to the manga .
Related : embodiment : What Happened To Aang After The Last Airbender Ended
Consequently , both versions of the anime begin in skinny - selfsame fashion . The backstory and goals of Edward and Alphonse Elric are the same , and most of the major options and fictitious character persist in place . Big plot points from the first act occur in both show , and Arakawa ’s fictional universe work more or less by the same rules . But there ’s a stop around the installment 30 stain where the 2003Fullmetal Alchemistanimebegins to depart from the manga and begin to spin its own recital . Brotherhoodbegins animating untouched textile by episode 10 , which intend there are plenty of differences between the two variation .
The Homunculi
One of the biggest difference betweenFullmetal AlchemistandBrotherhoodlies in its villains . Both versions of the story sport the Homunculi as recurring enemy for the Elric chum , and since these characters appear early , their canonic purpose and overarch seven deadly wickedness theme remain reproducible . However , the backstory of each Homunculus and their true nature are completely alter . In the initial 2003 Zanzibar copal series , eachHomunculusis the unintended issue of an alchemist undertake human transmutation - the " sin " of alchemy returning to haunt the Jehovah . Lust was bear when Scar ’s brother tried to raise his lady friend , Sloth was the result of Ed and Al stress to bring back their female parent , Wrath appeared from Izumi ’s failed transubstantiation , and Greed , Envy , Pride and Gluttony were all created by the series ' mischievous - scoundrel . InBrotherhood , the entire Homunculus blood change - all of the creatures are just made by the main villain , Father .
As well as their backstories , each Homunculus also experiences vastly different journeys in the 2003 serial andBrotherhood . Sloth is a motherly woman inFullmetal Alchemist , get as the secretary to King Bradley who is revealed to be Pride . InBrotherhood , Sloth is merely a burrow - dig monster , while Pride is King Bradley ’s son and the King himself is Wrath . Because of Lust ’s sympathetic origin story in the 2003Fullmetal Alchemistanime , she align with theElric brother , but her destruction post Gluttony into a state of depression . Brotherhood ’s Gluttony is actually Father ’s failed attempt at produce a Gate of Truth and the Homunculus end up being killed by Pride . Where Ed defeat Greed in the original Zanzibar copal series , the Homunculus is becharm and transfer into someone else inBrotherhood . As a by - product of the 2003 anime ’s Homunculus mythology , the cadaver of the transmuted humans playact as a failing to their several villains .
Envy ’s write up is one of the boastful changes . TheFullmetal Alchemistanime picture this Homunculus as a serpent - alike existence , who wanted to observe its father through the Gate of Truth , but the terminal form ofBrotherhood ’s enviousness is a one - eyed blob who eventually take its own life , consumed by its own green-eyed monster .
Related : Attack On Titan Basement Reveal : The Eldians ' Origin & Marley
Fullmetal Alchemist’s Villain - Dante & Father
When the firstFullmetal Alchemistanime began to cover its own original material , the story had yet to reveal its honest scoundrel , so was force into concoct a sweet resister - a mysterious woman hollo Dante . Centuries old , Dante was the lover of the Elric brothers ' begetter , Hohenheim . The couple managed to continuously cheat death using philosopher ’s stone , but after Hohenheim deck Dante for Trisha Elric , his ex resorted to using Homunculi as her minions , promising she could furbish up their human sort . After Dante ’s pursuance for eternal life is exposed , she ’s kill by her own servant , Gluttony , who she antecedently sent on a mindless feeding rampage .
Dante does n’t live inBrotherhoodor the original manga , and the primary baddie is alternatively revealed to be Father - the original Homunculus . Similar to the 2003 gum anime but without the romance angle , Edward andAlphonse ’s dad is much older than he seems , and was once a slave to an alchemist who created Father based on Hohenheim ’s profligate . Father took on a life of its own and cabal to ensure that the entire country of Xerxes would be sacrificed to allow him with a right strong-arm form . Thrown into the bargain , Hohenheim himself is made immortal , although he had no knowledge of the conspiracy and later devotes his life to defeating Father .
Edward & Alphonse Elric
As the primary protagonists ofFullmetal Alchemist , Edward and Alphonse Elric are n’t considerably spay between the two gum anime series . The brothers ' excogitation , personality and motivations stay largely reproducible , with most of the changes bump around them rather thantothem . With that said , there are a few alteration to Ed and Al ’s personal story and characterizations . For example , the State Alchemist exam is a proper exam in the earlierFullmetal Alchemistanime . Ed trains for the occasion under Shou Tucker and then baby-sit a proper test alongside other budding candidates . Ed ’s prodigal endowment gets the better of the billet inBrotherhood -all the tiny alchemist does to attain his qualification is transmute a spear and threaten King Bradley with it .
The extent of the Elric brother ' abilities is also more or less castrate between anime serial . In the 2003 iteration , Ed is up to of performing alchemy without the need to draw a transmutation rope , making him one of the most gifted in his theater of operations . Alphonse , on the other hand , still require to suck regular transubstantiation dress circle , at least until he find the power of a philosopher ’s Oliver Stone . InBrotherhood , however , both Elric brothers can execute lot - less alchemy thanks to their dabbling in human transmutation .
Related : Every Anime Series Parodied By One - Punch Man
Altered Fullmetal Alchemist Characters
Although Ed and Al do n’t change importantly , plenty of otherFullmetal Alchemistcharacters do . broadly speaking speak , Brotherhoodmoves at a fast pace , despite having a higher episode count , which means that the 2003 anime serial takes more time to search certain figures . Edward and Alphonse ’s female parent Trisha is a prime example , with far greater color to her character in the 2003 edition . InBrotherhood , Trisha is more of a plot machine to get theFullmetal Alchemiststory rolling . In the same vein , the Elric brother develop strong bonds with Maes Hughes and his family than they do inBrotherhood , and even assist deliver the Isle of Man ’s child . After appear early in the story , Rose is more important in the original anime , as Dante plans to use the girl as a brand new vas .
Conversely , someFullmetal Alchemistcharacters enjoy more substantial roles inBrotherhood , most notably Riza , whose connection to Mustang is explored in more detail , and Tim Marcoh , who is vote out by Gluttony in the first anime , but enjoy a much great part inBrotherhood .
Rather than being more prominent in one series than the other , some characters ' stories are equally vital but markedly unlike . The man creditworthy for killing Winry ’s parent is revealed to be Roy Mustang in the 2003Fullmetal Alchemistanime , but Scar charge the criminal offense inBrotherhood . Meanwhile , Brotherhoodsees Mustang go unsighted as a solvent of entering the Gate of Truth and a completely vamp storey in invented for Scar . This shady character ’s firstanimebackstory involves an nameless alchemist brother who supercede Scar ’s sleeve with a philosopher ’s Harlan F. Stone . redeem himself somewhat , Scar dies to protect Alphonse . Brotherhoodchanges this , and Scar ’s baron rather get along from combine alchemy with alkahestry . Scar also survives until the end of the narrative , helping overcome the Homunculi , and his personality is generally more focused .
Further altered characters include Shou Tucker , who becomes a chimera in the 2003 Zanzibar copal and seek to bring back his girl Nina , who he previously merged with the family dog . cicatrice puts paid to any such redemption story inBrotherhoodby redecorate the way with Tucker ’s viscera .
Missing Characters & Places
Because theFullmetal Alchemistmanga was still ongoing when the first gum anime aired , there are many gain to Arakawa ’s storey that would n’t make it into the 2003 series and vice versa . TheTV - original materialadds the Tringham brothers to the mix - a couple of young alchemists posing as Edward and Alphonse to access state resources and finish their father ’s research . Although this hoagy - plot does n’t feature inBrotherhood , it does derive from a twisting - off novel . The first anime series also interchange Hughes with the definitely less favorable Frank Archer . Elements of Arakawa ’s manga that featured alone inBrotherhoodinclude the Briggs soldiers and the nation of Drachma , as well as the Xing country and everyone associated with it . The Methedrine alchemist Isaac McDougal is also undivided toBrotherhood , but is n’t from the original manga .
Related : Boruto : portend The Next 2 Hokage After Naruto Uzumaki
The Ending & The Real World
give that the twoFullmetal Alchemistanime series take such contrasting path , it ’s no surprise that they conclude in wholly different ways . For the first Zanzibar copal serial , the Gate of Truth is uncover to be a portal site to the " real " world , and alchemy is explicate as energy created by asleep souls that slip by through the gate . Edward enters the logic gate , state his own biography as tantamount exchange payment and restore his brother ’s eubstance , pin himself in twentieth 100 Earth while Al and Winry remain on the other side . This tragical ending is expand upon in theConqueror of Shambalamovie , in which Alphonse manages to reunify with his brother on Earth shortly before the outbreak of World War II . Not great timing .
None of this happens inFullmetal Alchemist : Brotherhood . In a much happy ending , Ed only has to yield for the income tax return of Al ’s body with his ability to perform alchemy , and this process also restores his own lacking branch . Despite no longer being able to practice alchemy , Ed settle down and starts a family with Winry , living a peaceable liveliness without being drag through a portal and forced to worry about the looming darkness of Adolf Hitler .
More : Every Time Akira Toriyama Almost terminate Dragon Ball
