Related
Albus Dumbledore was at the forefront of our view of theHarry PotterHogwarts hierarchy . Throughout most of the franchise , he was in charge of the shoal and perform his post with kindness and a delicate sense of power . Despite this , there was a abbreviated bit in which Umbridge took his Emily Post and the final year with Snape at the helm . AfterDumbledore’sdeath , Minerva McGonagall became headmistress briefly , and after The Battle Of Hogwarts , she was given the role for good .
But who was better for the school ? We ’ve made a case for either side of the contest for leadership .
DUMBLEDORE WAS PERFECT: He Was The Only Person Voldemort Feared
As an incredibly brawny wizard , there was n’t much that Voldemort fear . He bang he could well overpower almost any wizard who got in his means and frequently practice this power .
The fact that Dumbledore was the only wizard that Voldemort feared and knew could overwhelm him meant that Hogwarts was always a beacon of guard for young wizards while Dumbledore was in explosive charge .
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MCGONAGALL: But That Made Dumbledore A Target
Despite Dumbledore ’s protection being a thanksgiving for Hogwarts School , it also made it a bit of a target . The fact thatDumbledorewas the only person Voldemort needed to kill for feel safe meant that he was a lasting target .
It ’s potential that Voldemort viewed himself as superior to McGonagall , so while her comportment at Hogwarts would n’t have made it secure , it would have been less of a target .
DUMBLEDORE WAS PERFECT: He Wasn’t Very Interested In Politics
It is widely recognise that Dumbledore was offer the position of Minister For Magic and turn it down , get on the stance of Hogwarts headmaster or else . Despite this , the incompetent Fudge often sought Dumbledore ’s advice .
The government ofHarry Potteris turbulent at the best of times , so the fact that Dumbledore had no interest in politics and frequently governed his life based on what was practiced for his students was a good matter for the school .
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MCGONAGALL: She Was Stern
One of the main progeny with Dumbledore ( specially in the first two films while he was played by Richard Harris ) was how gentle and calm he was .
This made people like him , but it did n’t really seem like how a headteacher should act . McGonagallwould just as happily punish a pupil ( if necessary ) as praise them .
DUMBLEDORE WAS PERFECT: He Had Unrivalled Intelligence
Going hand in hand with the fact that Dumbledore was the most powerful virtuoso in the franchise is the fact that he also seems to be the most intelligent .
He figured out Voldemort ’s Horcrux programme very early on on and was able to manoeuvre ( though in a needlessly complex way ) Harry towards triumph .
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MCGONAGALL: She Didn’t Show Favouritism
As mentioned above , McGonagallwas just as happy to punish as praise . This encompassed everyone from Malfoy to Hermione .
Dumbledore , as shown by his torturous technique of awarding Slytherin the house cup and then brutally award points to Gryffindor and overturning the answer , indicate monumental favouritism towards his own house and a blue-ribbon few students . Obviously , this is n’t what a schoolmaster should be doing .
DUMBLEDORE WAS PERFECT: He Trusted His Students
While we mostly sawDumbledoreinteract with Harry , the manner he verbalise to him and leave him with crucial missionary post shew something authoritative in a pupil - instructor relationship : reliance .
The fact that Dumbledore brought Harry with him to attain the locket despite roll in the hay how life - threatening it was going to proves that he really did trust his students . Or some of them , at least .
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MCGONAGALL: She Didn’t Talk In Riddles
Dumbledore ’s full-grown ever defect was his insistence on let the cat out of the bag in complex riddle that forthwith led to unnecessary Death . Not give Harry the full story as he did n’t want to make him finger even more pain makes mother wit , but it slowed things down .
Forcing him , Ron and Hermione might have been a learning experience for them , but not providing them with every act of information he had as soon as he had it literally cost life .
DUMBLEDORE WAS PERFECT: He Could Have Fun
Despite being the cause of many lost lives , Dumbledore also select the time to rent his fuzz down every now and again .
He was fond of sweets ( his password was ‘ Sherbet Lemon ’ , he had Glycyrrhiza glabra snap bean in his office and was partial to a Bertie Bott ’s Every Flavoured Bean ) and was even known to crack a joke or two .
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MCGONAGALL: But So Could She
Having said that , McGonagallwasn’t all sincerity and transfiguration . We saw her truly excited when she bring the Hogwarts statues to life story , and inThe Goblet Of Fire , she both taught Ron how to trip the light fantastic , and had a dancing withDumbledore .
Despite having a grim , flimsy - lipped fount most of the time , her ready wit imply she also dropped some average one - lining every now and again .
NEXT : Harry Potter : Hagrid ’s 10 unspoiled Quotes , rank
