Related
Fred and George Weasley are two of the most dear character in theHarry Potterseries . Their mischievous nature makes them difficult to dislike , and they provide amusing relief for a great many scenes in both the books and the movies . In addition to their sense of humor , the twin have prove that they are both talented and well-informed , with a knack for champion innovation . With so many prescribed caliber , it ’s difficult to opine aHarry Potterfan hold anything negative to say about them .
As it twist out , however , no character is nontaxable from critique . While Fred and George ’s buff alkali is large , there are still always those who are willing to share oppose views . These mortal took to Reddit , and bravely declare their truly unpopular opinions about the Weasley Twin Falls .
They Are Cruel
Fred and George are the social class clowns of Hogwarts School , but they will sometimes act upon for a jape at the disbursal of others . Most of the time , their victims are either Slytherin bookman , or their siblings , but these jokes did n’t ride well with all audiences .
RedditorHey_people_hows_lifepointed out an instance where Fred and George " booed a first - year Slytherin for just being a Slytherin . " They pointed out how this might have felt to that student , who was just mad to be attend Hogwarts . While the joke was all part of the contention between school Houses , it may have seemed too mingy from other perspectives .
They Lack Empathy
The Weasley twins loved to loosen up a tense minute with a good joke or two . However , some of their jokes might have been a act look - deaf to the people that were hurting as a result of those moments .
While RedditorSome_King_of_Fanlargely oppose the twins against other Redditors ' criticisms , they did include that " empathy was n’t a strong suit " for Fred and George . They often wish more about getting a laugh than being sensitive to the unmanageable times that their Friend and family were going through . These jokes may not have been mean in nature , but they just did n’t take others ' feelings into considerateness .
Their Products Are Unethical
Joke store item are never really meant to be kind , but some of Fred and George ’s inventions may have been take things a morsel far . " Anyone who sell ' love potion ' is a bit shady in my record , " saidCalm - Sail2472 , feeling that the love potion were ways to annihilate the victim ’s ability to give consent .
The potion became a difficult obstacle for Harry , who was have to be careful about what he wipe out in case someone had slipped him a love potion . Had they succeeded , Harry would have been the dupe of rape - as many buff have pointed out over the year , the concept of legal ' love potion ' is deeply debatable . Of course , this is problematic in the Wizarding World as a whole , not just with Fred and George .
They Didn’t Face Enough Discipline
Fred and George often said that they drop more time in detention than not , but it never seemed to put out them . Despite the detention , the twobroke almost every Hogwarts School Rule , leading some Reddit users to think that the teachers were n’t making much exertion to punish them .
" The twins could do whatever they wanted because they were top Quidditch players , " saidGriezz , reminding their fellow Redditors that Professor McGonagall cared " more about her team get ahead than doing her line . " It ’s difficult to say if take away them from the team would have changed anything , but no one seemed uncoerced to judge .
They Are Overrated
Some Redditors felt that there was nothing untimely with Fred and George themselves , but that some fans grant them more love than they deserved . UserAaeiynsimply state , " they ’re overrated . "
When it comes down to it , audiences never begin to see too many side to the twins . They were only the endless jokesters . Since they were only serious for short burst of clock time , it was laborious to get the know the complexities of their reference . Without those complexities , someHarry Potterfans might recollect that they are n’t interesting enough characters for how big their fanbase is .
They’re Obnoxious
Humor has a time and place , but sometimes class clowns do n’t understand when it ’s time to block up . This is exactly how RedditorLadySygerrikdescribed Fred and George , also express that if they were to meet the twins in real life they would likely " get rile by their put-on pretty regularly .
Fred and George are not main fiber of the series , so it is even possible that if they were an immediate part of Harry ’s group in the book and movies , interview might have old-hat of their energy . Fans still often call forFred and George Weasley to receive their own spin - off movieabout their days at Hogwarts , so if this were the case , the movie would not execute well .
They Were Sadistic
Many of the twin ’s prank item uncover that they love find out citizenry in discomfort . Most mass are willing to express joy along with the joke , but this kind of humor does n’t fly for everyone , such as Hermione .
When Hermione ridicules the boy for their caper , they will often express joy at her and impeach her of having no sensory faculty of humour . One Reddituserwas ofttimes annoyed by this , say that " anytime Hermione disaccord with the twins , " they tended to take Hermione ’s side over the twins . Hermione often showed she had a sensation of humour , she just did n’t pleasure in other people ’s pain .
They Weren’t Funny
Pranks away , Fred and George still have some good crack and one - liners . Their sensation of humor gave the serial publication a levity , and some of the best consequence in theHarry Potterbooks were the insignificant sceneswhere the twins made everyone laugh in the Gryffindor common room .
Comedy is subjective , though , and some Redditors found that they never quite laughed out loud like other fan did when watching or reading Fred and George ’s scenes . One Reddituserwent as far as to say that " their jape are pretty sh*tty , " in their opinion .
They Were Cowards
When Fred and George set off fireworks and used some of themost impressive spells inHarry Potterto curse the corridor throughout the castle , just before ditch the shoal and their academic success for good , most rooter see it as a exultant resistance to Umbridge and her gothic means of run a school . However , one Redditor see this scene differently .
" Thought they were a bountiful good deal but went run scared when the good professor , Umbridge , took them on , " said RedditorDirectSpeaker3441 . This mail , which is potential the most unpopular opinion of them all , greatly negate the views of most , who would see the Weasley Twins as hero , and Umbridge , very distinctly , as the villain .
They Were Horrible Brothers
Big brothers can be fell , but Fred and George could be especially nasty to Ron . As the youngest boy of the Weasley family , Ron had a lot of eminent expectations to live up to , and his elderly twin brother never helped him experience like he could ever sum up up .
" They gave Ron arachnophobia , burned a hole inside his clapper , beat his pet Puffskein to decease , give the Marauder ’s Map to Harry or else of their blood brother , and mocked his insecurities all the clip , " said one Reddituser . While fan of the twin might be capable to argue that they are funny , it ’s gruelling to fence that they were kind older brothers .
NEXT:10 Harry Potter Book Moments That Should ’ve Been In The Movies , According To Ranker
