The Haunting of Hill House
Although Disney’sEncantois beloved by young looker , the hit crime syndicate animation secretly recreated the plot of Colorado - writer Charise Castro Smith ’s darker , more ripe Netflix success , The Haunting of Hill House . Encanto ’s magical reality is not entirely unfamiliar to many of those who sleep together the revulsion and illusion genres . The Disney musical ’s narration of a family with wizardly gifts whose life sentence are thrown into muddiness by a dreary secret blends relatable family dynamics with more fantastic chemical element in much the same direction that , for example , Twilightused vampire mythologyto showcase the heightened emotions of teenage beloved on a genuine degree .
As such , it may not come as a big surprise for fans ofEncantoto learn that one of the moving picture ’s co - writer , playwright Charise Castro Smith , has a account with repulsion . Not only did Castro Smith compose a pair of acclaimed horror plays , but the screenwriter also worked on Netflix ’s loose adaptation of Shirley Jackson ’s classical horror novel , The Haunting of Hill House . What may surprise some viewers ofEncanto , though , is find out just how many similarities there are between the crime syndicate - favorable attain andThe Haunting of Hill House .
Related : How Midnight Mass ' Reviews Compare To Hill House & Bly Manor
It ’s the story of a supernaturally - powered family whose magical home turns against them , forcing the sibling to look past their difference and into the dark cataclysm that defined their parent ’s pasts . Encanto , or co - screenwriter Charise Castro Smith ’s earlier gain , The Haunting of Hill House ? AlthoughMidnight Mass ’s Mike Flanaganwas also central to the creation ofThe Haunting of Hill House , Castro Smith dish as both a author and monitor manufacturer on the critically acclaimed 2018 hit . Its influence on her recent oeuvre is evident , as prove by a equivalence betweenEncanto ’s character and those ofThe Haunting of Hill House .
The Haunting of Hill House and Encanto’s Story Similarities Explained
BothEncantoandThe Haunting of Hill Houseare about magical house that are inhabited by a family unit of mismatched siblings who are apparently afflicted with a generational curse ( or blessing , inEncanto ’s font ) , the nature of which is gradually revealed in the twisty story . Both families also feature some strikingly alike fibre , which are in particular celebrated since - similar latersuccessor seriesThe Haunting of Bly Manor - The Haunting of Hill House ’s characters are not derived from the root textile in a rigid sense . The Crain family of Netflix’sThe Haunting of Hill Housegain their forenames from the Jackson novel , but their characters and their family relationships are altogether the Netflix show ’s creation . With this in mind , their law of similarity to character found in Castro Smith ’s laterEncantois happen upon .
The Haunting of Hill House and Encanto’s Shared Characters
legion characters inThe Haunting of Hill Housecan be paired withEncantocounterparts . Notably , Castro Smith is credited as the writer of numerous episode ofThe Haunting of Hill House , whereas serial creator Mike Flanagan has the sole writing credits for thelater Netflix horror hitMidnight Mass. The Haunting of Hill House ’s Theo has a similitude inEncanto ’s Luisa , with both being strong , ego - contained sisters who decline to let too much of the outside world in lest they feel crushed by it . The Haunting of Hill House ’s tragic addict Luke has a similitude inEncanto ’s anti - villain Bruno , with both being the seemingly erratic , but in secret sweet and well - meaning little chum of the family who is blamed for many of its issues , whileThe Haunting of Hill House ’s Nell has a mirror inEncanto ’s Mirabel . Both characters are untested heroine who pull the house ’s attention to the house ’s grip on their lives at great monetary value to themselves .
Luisa and Theo’s Similarities Explained
Encanto ’s Luisa gained a vocal hit with her solo song about struggling with the weight unit of expectations station on her by her house and the beleaguer community . likewise , futureMidnight MassheroineKate Siegel ’s Theo must equilibrise attempting to keep her family together with maintaining her mental health while also stifle the traumatizing impact of her piece of work as a children ’s counselor . Both characters have ways of keeping the outside world at bay ( Luisa ’s forcible intensity and Theo ’s dipsomania ) , but both of these coping strategies eventually fail them and see the apparently substantial vernal women forced to face their greatest reverence , which is opening up to others about their insecurity and sharing the core of their fears with loved unity .
Related : Midnight Mass Wasted Its Scariest Twist
Bruno and Luke’s Similarities
Both scapegoats , Encanto ’s Bruno andThe Haunting of Hill House ’s Luke are uncomfortable with their power to see the world behind glossy veneers . While Oliver Harper Jackson’sInvisible ManandThe Haunting of Bly Manorvillain rolesmade use of the worker ’s intimidate height to depict him as a traditional opposer , Luke is impersonate as a tragic antihero whose huge skeleton and growling baritone mask a heart of gold and a disarmingly innocent disposition . likewise , Bruno is made out to be a monstrous maniac in his prefatory song , only for the inimitable John Leguizamo ’s spirited vocal performance to try the lineament is a harmless , soulful sweetheart who has been misunderstood by his family .
They ’re also both ostracized by their respective families as a result of their power to see through cheerful facades , with Luke and Bruno being depicted as dangerous figures on the outskirts of the story at first . However , EncantoandThe Haunting of Hill Houseboth continue to right the record and show that Luke and Bruno are some of each family ’s strongest and most well - intentioned members . In this respect , the two characters evidence polar to the conclusions of each storey .
Nell and Mirabel’s Similarities Explained
Perhaps the saddest similarity betweenThe Haunting of Hill HouseandEncanto ’s stories add up in the mannikin of Nell and Mirabel ’s contrasting plots . Both character reunite their families by force them to face their collective hurt instead of continuing to ignore their past . However , Encantonot only sees Mirabel survive her attempt to uncover the kinsfolk ’s story , but the heroine even finish up being able to touch on her kinsperson casa ’s magic in the movie ’s finish . In demarcation , The Haunting of Hill House ’s Nell faces an ending about as optimistic asMidnight Mass ’s downbeat conclusion . Although her ego - sacrifice impart her family together , Nell reunites the Crains through her suicide . Her death is arguably the most heartbreaking import in a deeply drear series , withThe Haunting of Hill HouseinvertingEncanto ’s plot , since uprooting the category ’s past is not enough to save the heroine in this translation of issue .
More : How Midnight Mass ' Episode 2 One - Shot Compares To Hill House ’s
