The Godfather
mobster movies have a prospicient and storied history . Hollywood has been making motion picture about gangsters for tenner , with famous movies likeScarfaceandWhite Heatbeing especially pop throughout the XXX and 40s . The genre has progressed through the age and is now mostly connected with Martin Scorsese , who has maneuver many a famous mobster flick .
Of course , there are many classic mobster films out there . But do they really deserve that " Graeco-Roman " pedigree ? There are also many ungratifying mobster movie out there that merit more respect and attention . These are five mobster moving-picture show that are right smart underrated , and five that are overrate .
UNDERRATED: The Godfather Part III (1990)
The first twoGodfatherfilms are undeniable classics . Given how the first two are often herald as some of the best movies ever made , The Godfathersaga could have wrapped withPart IIand no one would have plain .
But sixteen years afterPart IIcamePart III , and no one seemed to care for it . It grossed just $ 136 million and received comparatively mild to poor reviews . Still , it ’s a somewhat self-colored and well - crafted movie , but it unfortunately pales in the shadow of two cinematic legends .
OVERRATED: Scarface (1983)
IsScarfacea Graeco-Roman ? call for unlike people and you may receive dissimilar responses . To some , it ’s a classic that joyously leans into its moreoutlandishand ridiculous aspect . To others , it ’s a littletoooutlandish and ridiculous to be take seriously .
It want to be an epic gangster saga , but it ’s little more than a laud action picture show with some of the most famous depictions of violence ever committed to take . It also runs far too long , and Al Pacino ’s overacting may prove too wearisome for some viewer .
UNDERRATED: Road To Perdition (2002)
Road to Perditionis never really utter about when it comes to the great mobster dramas . It ’s more of a revenge thriller than gangster dramatic event , as it sees a crime syndicate enforcer searching for the person responsible for for shoot down his kinsfolk .
But if the report is a little generic , then the stiff carrying into action from Tom Hanks and Paul Newman , the gorgeous cinematography , and the unrelentingly somber flavour help elevateRoad to Perdition .
OVERRATED: Casino (1995)
Audiences had gamy prospect going intoCasino , as Scorsese and his team looked to capitalize on the hazardous success ofGoodfellas . alas , the squad fell a little flat withCasino . Despite containing many of the same elements , Casinocouldn’t quiterecapture the magic .
The story and editing are n’t as strain close , the pacing is all over the shoes , and the secret plan retreads intimate ground . Casinois a in effect movie , but nowhere nearly as beneficial as it should have been .
UNDERRATED: Miller’s Crossing (1990)
When it hail to the greatCoen brothersmovies , Miller ’s Crossingis often ignored in favour of more democratic whole kit and caboodle likeFargoandNo Country for Old Men .
Nevertheless , Miller ’s Crossingis a fantastic gangster drama with stylistic element of neo - noir and superb performances from the like of John Turturro and Steve Buscemi . While a box bureau turkey of the time ( grossing just $ 5 million),Miller ’s Crossingis now a cult , if vastly underappreciated , authoritative .
OVERRATED: The Irishman (2019)
Many the great unwashed wanted to likeThe Irishman , and it ’s possible that this do-or-die desire to do so clouded judgement . LikeCasino , there ’s no denying thatThe Irishmanis awell made movie . But , likeCasino , it could have been far dear than it in reality was .
For all its bravura , the movie hold a lot of defect , including the deceptive de - aging effects , the horrid tempo , and the extreme ( and highly unneeded ) runtime . It ’s a long movie that did n’t need or deserve its duration . It ’s epical for the interest of being larger-than-life , not through any need of its storytelling .
UNDERRATED: The General (1998)
The Generalis an Irish gangster moving picture that has check very small attention outside of its aboriginal country , which is a shame since it ’s a movie fans of the genre will sleep with .
The movie concerns real Irish rout party boss Martin Cahill , who was given the nickname ' The General ' by the medium . The movie contains a prima casting , include the always - greatBrendan Gleesonas Martin Cahill and Jon Voight as Inspector Ned Kenny . It ’s a very raw picture show , owing to its minuscule budget , but a very good film nevertheless .
OVERRATED: The Untouchables (1987)
LikeCasinoorScarface , The Untouchablesis one of those mobster picture show whose status as a classic remains questionable . It should have been much near than it actually is , comprise a great cast , an assured director , and a thrilling , can’t - mess - it - up real living story about the ruin of Al Capone .
However , some questionable directing , music choice , and acting bringThe Untouchablesdown to " pretty good " territory . It ’s not the mobster classic that many exact it is , despite some here and now of undeniable entertainment .
UNDERRATED: A History Of Violence (2005)
It is a horrifically violent movie , as most of the violence is depict in a realistically grisly mode to hammer in the brutality of such a lifestyle . Those who can count past the gore will bump a movie well worth appreciating .
OVERRATED: Carlito’s Way (1993)
The thirdBrian De Palma filmon this list , Carlito ’s Waysees De Palma and Al Pacino reuniting for his cult gangster classic about a reformed felon being pulled back into The Life . Despite being a cult classic and enjoying legions of sports fan who guard its caliber , Carlito ’s Wayrightfully earned lukewarm reviews upon release .
Despite hold unattackable functioning and some great set pieces , Carlito ’s Wayis an instantly forgettable motion picture that is less than the heart and soul of its parts . If you ’ve assure a gangster film about the hardships of being in and getting out of The Life , you ’ve seenCarlito ’s Way .
NEXT : Harry Potter : 5 Times Harry Potter Was An Overrated Character ( & 5 He Was Underrated )
