The Northman
Robert Eggers ' third directorial installment , The Northman , is a brute diachronic Viking photographic film . Chronicling Prince Amleth ’s journey of revenge , the moving-picture show surveys gory shot of fighting , themes of religion and mysticism , the household moral force , and masculinity in an heroic manner .
Although the Viking epic is impart by a star - constellate cast and refreshful takes on a pop moving-picture show sub - genre , there are some moviegoers with disagree thoughts . Many Reddit user have taken prison term to share their unpopular opinions onwhat Marc Maron calls"the Viking movie to end all Viking movies . "
It’s Just Retelling An Old Tale
Viking films are often bound by their own deficiency of versatility ; by nonremittal , they must include violence , woodsy setting , odd ritual , and more . UserMaximumGreen4134believes this is a massive weak point in the movie , arguing that it rarely breaks loose from what ’s already been done in Hollywood .
Related:10 Studio Movies That Should Be Robert Eggers ' Next Project After The Northman
He argues that the action scenes did n’t cark from the lack of originality , writing , " If the action scenes were great it at least would ’ve made up for the lack of creativity , but they were n’t . " While many might indicate for the depth of Amleth ’s story and family drama , it seems that some still had higher expectations of egger in impart to the Viking film arsenal .
It Just Feels Like A History Channel Docudrama
One of the most - praise points ofThe Northmanas well as Eggers ' other films is his balance of historic accuracy and cultural commentary . After all , for make an historic period - old tale relevant , it has to somehow relate to current interest .
Reddit useridapitbwidiuatabip , however , argues that this Viking picture uses historical truth to its own hurt . The picture show ’s costumes , script , and attention to ritual make for a want of overall fibre growth . While many thought of this film as far more riveting than daytime - meter television receiver , some see it as " amazingly well made , but it almost felt like a History Channel docudrama at points . "
It’s Eggers' Sellout Film
While many Redditors believe thatThe Northmanisone of the best movies of the twelvemonth so far , some manage that Robert Eggers give up nuance and creativity to make a " safe " cinema .
Reddit userPsychoticApeaffirms thatThe Northman"was a beautiful film , and a nifty Viking motion-picture show , " but also believes that this film is " less interesting and more by the number than Robert Eggers ' other two film . " To be sure , Eggers ' two previous projects , The LighthouseandThe Witchwere eclectic in many way . His third piece of work is perhaps less original , though many believe he keep his own vogue to the benefit of the Viking film .
There’s No Glory In The End
One of the central musical theme inThe Northmanwas dying an honorable expiry in battle and fix a Viking ’s bum in Valhalla . Almost every reference had opportunities to expose valorousness in the cheek of risk . The film ’s open up scenes introduce this ideal and its close supposedly solidifies Amleth ’s nimbus .
relate : The Northman Characters & Their Counterparts In Shakespeare ’s Hamlet
Reddit userAdorno_a_window , however , is not buying it . After expressing the overall gloominess of the film , he argues that other report add to the pic ’s want of article of faith , such as a neglect of " downtime and some more life in the movie . " These things combined seem to provide an overall unconvincing experience of the film ’s most climactic points .
There Are Too Many Celebrity Actors
The Northmanhasa cast that many have seen before , while still bringing lesser - make out actors to the screen . player that typically work with egger , such as Anya Taylor - Joy and Willem Dafoe , renew their collaboration with him , and he manages to bring in other big names like Nicole Kidman , Ethan Hawke , and Björk .
Redditorheadache92 , however , calls this problematic for the overall atmosphere of the film . The user ’s underpin points are that " it did initially shatter the illusion … it would have been decent to see some less spectacularly beautiful actors . Or even less forward-looking looking face . " Though the playing in the moving-picture show was phenomenal , some feel that familiar expression may get setbacks in sincerely immerse oneself in the story .
The Eldest Son Deserved Better
One of the least sympathetic characters in the movie may be Thorir the Proud , the eldest Logos of Fjölnir . He is just as his name alludes suggests : an implausibly lofty and entitled son that gibe the " son of the king " mentality , and he convey an excitable presence to the picture on many occasions .
relate : MBTI ® Of The Northman Characters
Despite Thorir ’s reputation , Reddit userdan-0O7believes that Thorir should have gone out in a in force way . This rooter " like the firstborn son got more of a theatric death , " claim it was severe to tell who had been toss off by Amleth , at first . Many viewing audience may have been satisfied that Thorir did not incur an attentive send - off , but some still may need a more elaborated demise , if only for clarity ’s sake .
Björk Was The Best
Across the intimately two - and - a - half - hour film , acclaimed Icelandic singer / songwriter and occasional actor Björk makes an on - silver screen appearance that lasts all of five minutes . The public presentation is surely telling , but few would call it the best vista in the movie debate other pivotal scenes such as Amleth recall the steel or the last scrap between him and Fjölnir .
RedditorMy_Favourite_Penargues that the scene is severely under - praised . " Nobody is talking about Björk ’s [ S]eeress scene , " they save . " Best scene in the film . " Björk ’s eerie enactment of a heady Wiccan guiding Amleth was praiseworthy , but may not bunk the shadow of the rest of the film .
It’s A Revenge Film With No Heart
One of Eggers ' inviolable endowment may be his power to compose a meaningful ( yet still accurate ) script . Therewere many quotable moments inThe Northmanthatproved that he has not misplace his touch in this regard . Some of the most emotional scene have meaningful citation that encapsulate the characters and their emotions .
Reddit userspredy123 , however , debate that not enough scenes place up the family moral force in the showtime " to make the release of the father palpate actually heartbreaking . " The fan take that " the movie had no heart … And without a solid excited tie-in to the characters , I personally had no stakes in the retaliation . "
Nicole Kidman Wasn’t Great
Nicole Kidman is an acclaimed actress , with an telling filmographyspanning many different style . She has continued to deepen her versatility and reliability as an actress , and many believe her execution as Queen Gudrún inThe Northmanfurther solidifies these trait .
Related : What Your Favorite Northman Character Says About You
But some Redditors , likeOldManHipsAt30 , trust that she was not a good casting choice for the mother of a vindictive Viking Logos . This drug user write , in a harsh way , " I reckon Kidman was horrible , but Skarsgård was amazing . " While few believe that Kidman ’s functioning was " horrible , " some still believe she did n’t fit the part or have the expert on - sieve chemistry with Prince Amleth .
It Should Have Just Been A TV Series
There are many long movies that span the three - hour mark easily , makingThe Northman’stwo - hour and 20 - mo runtime seem average . Its rushed moment and atmospheric preferences make for a distinctly movie - like feeling .
In contrast to this , however , Redditorsaintrellibelieves that it was too long . The user ascribe the long feeling to have too many extra scenes , claim that " the more it became a cool sort of culture piece the more it seemed like a miniseries that was misdiagnosed as a motion picture . " While most rooter may agree that there were some unnecessary scene , few argue that this film would be better off the big projection screen .
Next:10 Behind - The - Scenes Facts About The Northman
