Related
Star Warsis one of the most popular and well - loved franchises in the story of movie theater , with fans spanning the total ball , many of whom hold it as their pet pic series of all meter . This fandom has only raise in turn and elan over the last forty years .
While love life for any enfranchisement is admirable and often well - intentioned , it can be gentle to slip into heated arguments with other buff who have differing opinion than you do about your favorite movies . Star Warsis certainly no exclusion to this rule , as certainRedditorshave identified legion debates that the fandom will never stop suffer .
Anakin’s Force Ghost
One Redditor , Abject_Cellist_4896 , knows that fans will always argue over whether Anakin ’s Force Ghost at the end ofReturn of the Jedishould be present by Hayden Christianson or Sebastian Shaw , the original actor . They trust that this is " a generational payoff , depending on which version you develop up with . "
Fans have long wondered whether it is better to portray the touch of Anakin Skywalker as his young self just before twist to the Dark Side or his older , more weathered self after becoming free from his vices , as the original motion-picture show portray . As Christianson is likely recall for several moreStar Warsprojects , it may be that the odds will soon tip in his favour regarding this particular divergence .
Darth Jar Jar
While discuss the many debate that seem interminable among theStar Warsfandom , SmellyFatRollssuggested that we will always be left to argue if " Jar Jar Binks [ as ] a Sith Lord , " referring to the pop theory that Jar Jar , and not Palpatine , was the honest genius behind the fall of the Jedi .
Though this hypothesis originated as a joke , manyStar Warsfans turn away to conceive anything other than the idea that Jar Jar was a Sith all along , which would true serve several lingering dubiousness from the prequel trilogy . Nevertheless , no matter how much support this theory may receive , Darth Jar Jarwill always feel more like a parallelStar Warsuniverse .
AT-AT Armor
LordBaranofpoints out an inconsistency inThe Empire Strikes Back , wherein the AT - AT armour , which had been designated as " too potent for blasters , " quickly becomes penetrable after the walkers are bestow to the priming . This Redditor suggest that fan will never stop discussing this inconsistency , and just how it could be explained .
The Empire is one of the skilful factions in all ofStar warfare , which stand for that it has attained some of the best artillery known to the galaxy . As such , it makes no sense for the AT - AT walkers to of a sudden become vulnerable after hitting the land , though this peculiar public debate is more of an unanswered game hole .
Disney
RedditorTink2013may hold a vitriolic hatred toward a certain company that currently distributesStar Warsmedia , write that fan will always argue over the view of whether or not " Disney purposefully pop " the dealership . While their view is certainly opinionated , it is a legitimate stance that sure subjects of the fandom seem to take .
Star Warsfans have n’t all take kindly to Disney ’s skill of the attribute in 2012 , with some claiming they have drive the dealership into the ground . While some devotee may be stagnant - set against the House of Mouse ’s study with the serial , one must admit thatStar Warsfans have never had so much substance , with serial likeThe MandalorianandObi - Wan Kenobipermeating popular culture .
Hyperdrive Ram
Tra4c3_gamingpoints out the logic - deflect forfeiture of Admiral Holdo inThe Last Jedi , wherein she utilize her ship to crash into a First Order vas , jumping into hyperspace with the other ship in her sights . This substance abuser suggests that this outcome opens up " a pandora ’s box , " bay why character reference do n’t simply do this in every space struggle , specially those involving a Death Star .
This Redditor does bring up an interesting compass point , as it would seem that most problem in theStar Warsuniverse could be work with a ship used as a battering ram . While there are certain ships designed for just this intention within the canyon , it may be difficult for some to observe any succeeding space battles without wondering why someone does n’t simply give one ship by ramming it into another .
The Chosen One
RedditorAbject_Cellist_4896wonders if fans will ever get the response to the enquiry of whether or not " the [ Chosen One ] Prophecy was just a load of jazz , " designate out that the prophesied " balance to the Force " never really came about in the enfranchisement , as Anakin ’s Fall never brought an end to the Jedi - Sith dispute , but only accelerated them .
The Prophecy seems to be a story element that is allow entirely for the prequel series , which only create more questions than response . While such a major art object of chronicle could besomething that a spinoff about the Jedi could flesh out further , it feels as though the Prophecy was more an indication of the latter Jedi hubris than a licit prediction of the future .
Top Sith
A Redditor by the handle ofS_A_c_Kis somewhat surprised at the debate over whether Kylo Ren or Darth Vader was the stronger Force wielder . They claim that they would " care to hear both side of meat , " sparking a long and interesting discourse in the scuttlebutt department .
Both Kylo Ren and Darth Vader are portray as being supremely powerful in their respects . However , yield that Ren held Vader as his idol , it abide to understanding that he was cognizant that he did n’t quite measure up to his grandpa , though perhaps could have had he survived long enough to increase in his specialty .
The Special Editions
While listing several long - lastingStar Warsdebates , Nice - Yesterday-4211includes a reference to something that is indeed quite controversial in the fandom , indicating that " anything having to do with the Special Editions " is a neverending debate , referring to George Lucas ’s edits to the classic films tenner after their release .
A side effect of Lucas ’s change to his films is that the original cuts are implausibly hard to witness . As such , youthful genesis ofStar Warsfans may be completely unaware that variety were made to the original films at all . Nevertheless , older fans that remember the theatrical cutting of the Hellenic celluloid will never quite be content with the sudden overmuch of CGI part and strange sequences injected into their favored films .
Who Shot First?
" I ca n’t guess a universe whereStar Warsfans do n’t fight about whether Han or Greedo shot first , " writes Reddit userJiachobucci , contribute " It was Han , by the manner . " This post refers to the notorious confrontation inA New Hope , wherein Han kills the bounty huntsman Greedo , which has been ceaselessly altered by Lucasfilm to change the chronological succession of the scene ’s event .
This debate has almost become a symbolic representation of theStar Warsfandom ’s infighting , with the sequence itself most attaining a fanbase of its own . proponent of Greedo shooting first believe that Han is better represent in such an natural event , whereas those who trust Solo fired the first shot argue that doing so put the character as a morally gray wild card , who may fall on either the side of goodness or of evil .
Sequel Trilogy
LeeRoyTChas a intemperate opinion regarding the latest installments of the Skywalker Saga , believing that fans will have their work cut out for them in deciding whether " Episode VIII or IX is worse . " While they take to detest both , they also bring out a more important issue among theStar Warsfandom in that it remains very much divided on the merits of the sequel trilogy , with some very much in favour of the films and others dead - set against them .
Star Warshas often had problem earning devotee when it comes to raw cinematic capacity . Much like the prequels , Disney ’s sequel trilogy has encountered electric resistance upon its dismissal , with many lover openly mock the newfangled installments of the franchise . While it seems as though this debate over the sequels will last constantly , fan may yet take them just as they did the prequel films if given time .
NEXT:10 regretful thing That Ever find To Han Solo
